Seller Credits at a Richmond Closing: Limits by Loan Type and When They Beat a Price Cut

A seller credit is money the seller agrees to put toward your closing costs, and each loan type caps how much it can be. On a conventional loan backed by Fannie Mae, the cap is 3%, 6% or 9% of the price depending on your down payment. On a USDA loan it is 6%. VA guidance points to 4%. For FHA, ask your lender for the current handbook figure, because we could not confirm it on an official page we could open for this post.

This guide covers what a credit is, the limits we could verify, what a credit can and cannot pay for, how it interacts with the appraisal, and when asking for a credit is smarter than asking for a lower price. It is written for buyers across the Richmond area, from the City of Richmond to Chesterfield County and Henrico County.

What a seller credit is, in plain terms

You and the seller agree on a price. You also agree, in the contract, that the seller will pay a stated dollar amount toward your costs at settlement. The lender calls this an interested party contribution (IPC) or a seller concession. The seller still receives the contract price, less the credit. You bring less cash to the table.

A credit is not a discount on the home. The price on the contract stays the price, which matters for the appraisal and for how future buyers see comparable sales.

Limits by loan type

Each program sets its own ceiling. The table shows only what we read at the official pages named below it.

Read the Fannie Mae rule yourself in the Fannie Mae Selling Guide, B3-4.1-02. It measures the limit against the lower of the sales price or the appraised value, not the loan amount. Freddie Mac publishes its own limits in its Seller/Servicer Guide, and we did not read them for this post, so do not assume they match.

The USDA text sits in HB-1-3555, Chapter 6. It limits interested party concessions to six percent of the sales price. It lists three items outside that cap: lender-paid costs funded through premium pricing, funds for repairs, and funds to pay the buyer’s real estate commission.

For VA, the VA Home Loan Guaranty Buyer’s Guide says concessions can be up to 4%. One passage words the base as the loan amount and another as the sale. The guide sends readers to Chapter 8 of the Lenders Handbook, which we could not open. Ask your lender which base applies and what counts toward the 4%.

A worked example, using hypothetical numbers

Say a buyer writes an offer at $400,000 on a conventional loan. At that price, 3% is $12,000, 6% is $24,000 and 9% is $36,000, depending on which down payment bracket applies. A buyer putting down less than 10% could receive up to $12,000 in credits under the Fannie Mae table. A buyer putting down 20% could receive up to $24,000. The credit still cannot exceed the buyer’s actual closing costs.

What a credit can and cannot pay for

Credits are meant for the costs of getting the loan and closing it. Typical uses are lender fees, title charges, recording fees, prepaid taxes and insurance, and discount points to buy down the rate.

The limits we read show several things a credit cannot do:

• Down payment. The Fannie Mae page says IPCs cannot be used toward the borrower’s down payment, reserves or minimum borrower contribution.
• Personal items. USDA’s text bars contributions from paying the applicant’s personal debts or acting as an inducement through movable items such as furniture, cars or electronics.
• More than your costs. Fannie Mae treats any credit above the borrower’s closing costs as a sales concession.

If you are buying new construction, builders often offer their own incentives, and the rules for those are covered in builder incentives for Richmond new construction.

How a credit interacts with the appraisal

The appraiser values the home, not the deal. A credit does not raise or lower what the house is worth. It does matter in two ways.

First, the lender tests the credit against the limit using the lower of price or appraised value. If the appraisal comes in below your price, the dollar limit shrinks with it.

Second, anything over the limit is treated differently. The Fannie Mae page says concessions above the limit are treated as sales concessions: the sales price is reduced by that amount and the loan-to-value ratio is recalculated. That can change your loan amount and your cash needed at closing. This is why you should confirm the limit with your lender before the offer goes in, not after the appraisal.

When a credit beats a price cut

Neither one is always better. The choice depends on what is limiting you.

• Cash is the limit. If you can qualify but are short on closing cash, a credit helps more. A $10,000 credit goes straight to your closing costs, while a $10,000 price cut mostly shows up as a lower loan and a smaller monthly payment.
• Monthly payment is the limit. A price cut lowers the loan for the whole term. A credit used for discount points lowers the rate instead. Our guide to the refinance break-even point shows how to weigh points against the months you will stay in the home.
• Appraisal risk. If an offer is well above comparable sales, a credit on top makes the gap harder to defend. A lower price may be the cleaner fix.
• Future resale. A price with a credit records the higher price as a comparable sale. A price cut records the lower one. Which helps you depends on whether you are buying or planning to sell soon.

Sellers often prefer a credit over a cut for the same reason: the headline price stays where they listed it. If your offer might compete with others, our note on a backup offer on a home under contract explains where you stand in line.

Getting it into the contract

Write the credit as a fixed dollar amount, not a vague promise to “pay closing costs.” Tell your lender before you submit the offer so they can check it against the limit for your loan. The preferred lenders we work with can run it for you, and our mortgage calculator lets you compare a credit against a price cut yourself. Browse what is on the market now on our property search.

Frequently asked questions