Square Footage on a Listing, Tax Record and Appraisal: Why Richmond-Area Numbers Differ

Measuring tape lying on paper plans

A listing, a county tax record and an appraisal can show three different square footage numbers for the same house because each one measures a different way, at a different time, for a different purpose. A listing number can come from a seller, a builder plan or an old record. A county number comes from the assessor’s data. A lender’s appraisal follows a written measuring standard and treats basement space separately. When the numbers differ, ask where each one came from before you decide which one to trust.

This guide explains the measuring rules lenders use, what finished and unfinished mean for a basement, and what to do when the numbers disagree. It applies to homes in the City of Richmond, Chesterfield, Henrico, Hanover, Goochland and Powhatan.

How appraisers measure a house

Freddie Mac says it adopted the ANSI Z765 measuring method because gross living area had historically been measured inconsistently. In Freddie Mac’s ANSI FAQ, the standard’s above-grade finished area is treated as gross living area, and the sketch must be computer generated and show exterior dimensions. Fannie Mae’s June 2025 measuring fact sheet says measurements are taken to the nearest inch or tenth of a foot, and the final square footage is reported to the nearest whole square foot.

Both lenders apply it to detached single family homes, and Freddie Mac’s FAQ includes townhouses and side by side designs. Neither requires it for a desktop appraisal, and apartment style condos and two to four unit buildings are outside it. Accessory dwelling units must follow it.

Rule What the Fannie Mae fact sheet says
Minimum ceiling height for finished area 7 feet
Sloped ceiling rooms At least 50 percent of the finished floor area must have a ceiling of 7 feet or more
Lowest allowed point in finished area No part of the finished area below 5 feet
Sketch measurements Reported to the nearest tenth of a foot
Final square footage Reported to the nearest whole square foot
Staircases Count toward the floor they descend from
Two story foyers and similar openings Cannot be included as floor area

Finished space that fails the ceiling rules, or that you reach through unfinished space, is reported on its own line as nonstandard finished area instead of in the main number. That is one reason a bonus room or attic finish can show up in a listing but not in an appraisal total.

Finished versus unfinished basement

This is where most disagreements start. Under the standard, a floor level is partly or fully below grade if any portion of its walls is not entirely at or above ground level. Fannie Mae says any space that is partially or completely below grade must be reported as below grade area. Freddie Mac adds that below grade space counts as basement, finished or not.

In practice, a lender’s appraiser lists above grade finished area, below grade finished area and unfinished area as separate items. A listing that adds a finished basement into one total can look larger than an appraisal’s headline figure even when both are honest. Finished also has limits: a basement room with a low ceiling, or one reached through an unfinished area, may be reported as nonstandard finished area.

When you read a listing, check whether the number includes below grade space. If the listing does not say, ask. A basement can add real living space for you, but lenders compare homes using their reporting rules, so the two views do not always line up.

Why the three numbers do not match

  • Different methods. A listing may come from a builder plan, a seller’s estimate, a past appraisal or the tax record. An appraisal under ANSI Z765 measures the exterior and applies the ceiling rules above.
  • Different dates. A county record can predate an addition, a finished attic or a converted garage. Chesterfield reassesses real estate every year, with notices mailed by February 1 showing values as of January 1, according to the Chesterfield assessments page. A change after the inspection date may not appear yet.
  • Different purposes. A tax record exists to assess value in bulk. A listing exists to market a home. An appraisal exists to support a loan.
  • Different coverage. Desktop appraisals do not have to follow ANSI, and outbuildings are generally outside it, so those numbers can come from a looser method.

The county search pages are a useful first check. Chesterfield provides its Real Estate Assessment Data database, Henrico runs its own assessment division and a recorded size can be tested through its review process, and the City of Richmond’s assessor offers a Property Search tool on rva.gov. Pull each record and compare it with the listing before you tour.

Compare homes by how they are measured, not just how they are advertised

Tell us your areas and the size you need, and we will set up a saved search across the City of Richmond, Chesterfield, Henrico, Hanover, Goochland and Powhatan. When a listing’s square footage looks off, we help you ask the right questions before you write an offer.

Set up my saved search

What to do when the numbers differ

  1. Ask for the source. Ask the listing agent where the square footage came from, and whether it includes any below grade or nonstandard space.
  2. Pull the county record. Compare finished area, number of levels and any additions with what you see on the tour.
  3. Look for a floor plan. Plans, permits or a past appraisal can explain a gap.
  4. Match your plan to the number. If you need three finished bedrooms on the main levels, count those rooms yourself rather than relying on a total.
  5. Talk to your lender early. The lender’s appraiser sets the value that supports the loan. VA loans are an example: the VA says a no down payment loan is possible only if the sale price does not exceed the appraised value, so a measuring difference can affect your cash needed. Our preferred lenders page lists lenders who can walk you through it.
  6. Use your contract timeline. Raise the question before your inspection and appraisal deadlines, not after.

If an appraisal comes in lower than the price, the next steps depend on your loan and your contract. Our guide to seller credits and limits by loan type explains how credits interact with loan rules, and if you are weighing a house for its lot or structure, our tear down and rebuild checklist covers how to look at a home that you may not keep.

If you think the county record is wrong

Each county sets its own review path. In Henrico, the real estate assessment appeal page says appeals are due April 1 at 11:59 p.m. EST and lists incorrect property data as a valid ground. It says a reviewer can look at size, condition and bathroom count, that an appraiser can measure buildings to verify square footage records, and that the record is updated if a property is larger than shown. In Chesterfield, the appeal page gives March 15 as the application deadline and April 15 as the Board of Equalization filing deadline, and tells owners to review their records for accuracy. For the City of Richmond, Richmond BizSense reported in April 2024 that owners first file an office review and can then go to the Board of Equalization, and that about 30 percent of office review appeals from 2019 to 2023 succeeded.

Those deadlines are for the owner of record, not a buyer in contract, and they change with each year’s calendar. Confirm the current dates on the county site.

Not legal advice: this is general information, not legal advice. If a contract states a square footage or you are thinking about an appeal, ask a Virginia real estate attorney how it applies to you.

Where to go from here

Start with the numbers you can check, then compare homes side by side in our property search. If you are new to the process, our buyer page explains how we work with you.

Start with a saved search

We will watch the City of Richmond, Chesterfield, Henrico, Hanover, Goochland and Powhatan for homes that fit your size needs, and flag any listing where the square footage needs a second look.

Set up my saved search

Written by the Mission Realty Team. Real Broker LLC, 3701 Cox Rd, Richmond, VA 23233, (804) 601-4960. Meet the people behind the blog on our team page.

Frequently asked questions

Does ANSI Z765 apply to condos and townhouses?

Freddie Mac says it applies to townhouses and side by side designs, but not to apartment style condos or two to four unit dwellings. Fannie Mae also excludes apartment and multifamily buildings and requires it for accessory dwelling units.

Does a two story foyer count toward square footage?

Not under Fannie Mae’s measuring fact sheet. It says openings to the floor below, such as two story foyers, cannot be included. Staircases count toward the floor they descend from.

What is nonstandard finished area?

Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae use the term for finished space that fails the standard’s requirements, such as the ceiling height rules, or that is reached only through unfinished space. It is reported separately from the main finished area total.

Can an appraiser opt out of the standard?

For full interior and exterior appraisals, Fannie Mae’s June 2025 fact sheet says appraisers cannot opt out and that the old exception code was retired. Freddie Mac still describes an exception code for cases where the appraiser cannot comply, and a declaration for exterior only and plans based work. Rules change, so ask your lender which version applies.

Does the appraiser’s number change the county record?

No. The appraisal supports your loan. The county record changes only through the county’s own review process. Henrico says its record is updated when a property is found to be larger than shown.

How often do the counties update assessments?

Chesterfield says it reassesses real estate every year, with notices mailed by February 1 showing values as of January 1. Henrico’s appeal page says the county reassesses each year and opens applications after the reassessment. Check the City of Richmond’s assessor site for its schedule.

Do online home value estimates count as proof of square footage?

Henrico’s appeal page says online estimates are not sufficient evidence for an appeal. Measurements, plans, permits and recent comparable sales carry more weight in a county review.

Can I hire my own measurement?

Many buyers ask an inspector or a licensed appraiser to measure when the numbers matter to the purchase. Henrico’s page notes that an appraiser can measure buildings to verify records. Ask your agent how this fits your contract timeline and cost.






Check out this article next

Wildlife and Rodents in Attics, Crawl Spaces and Walls: What Richmond-Area Buyers Should Check

Wildlife and Rodents in Attics, Crawl Spaces and Walls: What Richmond-Area Buyers Should Check

What an inspector can and cannot say about rodents and wildlife, who removes them in Virginia, safe cleanup steps from the CDC and EPA, and…

Read Article